Pedro Arantesrose
ArticlesContactNow

Goodhart's Law

It stands that a measure ceases to be a good measure when it becomes a target.
#charles-goodhart
Zettelkasten, June 22, 2021 (changes)

Notes

  • It stands that a measure ceases to be a good measure when it becomes a target.

  • Charles Goodhart advanced this idea in 1975.

  • When we pick a feature of the economy as an indicator of the economy, it ceases to function as that indicator because people start to game it.

    • The same happens to statistical variables.
  • It's a system mental model because it explains how a system works when a measure becomes the target.

  • Using multiples targets avoids Goodhart's Law because you must increase them all, not only one.

  • If you measure people on the number of nails made, you might get many tiny nails. If you measure the weight of nails made, you might get a few giant and heavy nails.

  • Educational systems that measure the students by grades incentivize them to memorize content for a test, then promptly forget it all.

Questions

  • How do you avoid Goodhart's Law?

References

RecommendationsDo you want to see all posts instead?
System Mental Models
System mental models are models that are used to help you understand how a system works.
Zettelkasten, April 23, 2021
Mental Models
Mental models are frameworks, worldviews, representations, or explanations of how something works. They're how we understand the world.
Zettelkasten, April 06, 2021
Natural Planning Model
It's the more effective way to think about projects and situations because it makes thinks happen sooner, better, and more successfully.
Zettelkasten, June 07, 2021
Reactive Planning Model
When a team starts a project without planning ahead, it's possible that the reactive planning model ensues.
Zettelkasten, June 06, 2021
People Systematically Overlook Subtractive Changes
When faced with a problem, people tend to prefer solutions that add new elements rather than removing elements, even if removing is the more efficient solution.
Zettelkasten, April 23, 2021
Hyperbolic Discounting
This theory states that humans discount the value of a later reward, by the factor that increases with the length of the delay.
Zettelkasten, April 06, 2021
Brandolini's Law
It states that debunking false, facetious, or otherwise misleading information requires much more energy than producing it.
Zettelkasten, July 04, 2021

Newsletter

Every Tuesday, I publish my most recent readings and thoughts. Subscribe to my newsletter if you want to follow topics about #startups, #mental-models, #cryptocurrencies, and more. You can also check my past issues on Revue.

By subscribing, you agree with Revue’s Terms and Privacy Policy